Planning for Thanksgiving 2011 began a few weeks ago when Matt and I decided to stay in Saint Paul for the weekend. Actually it was in the works prior to that because we’d decided that even if we went to Wisconsin or Iowa to celebrate with our families, we’d cook a second Thanksgiving dinner ourselves. A little ambitious? Yes. Also ambitious: cooking nine dishes for two people. That’s why I made sweet potato casserole and spinach balls to eat during the week leading up to Thanksgiving, so I’d only have to make seven things for Thanksgiving day. It’s called being sensible. Did I mention that I also made two pies for two people? It’s not Thanksgiving without options, is it? It’s also not Thanksgiving without a few blunders, which is why I made sure to slice a couple of fingers, burn my arm, burn the last of my pecans that were destined for a last-minute pecan tart, and buy a bag full of moldy chestnuts from Trader Joe’s. This year I am thankful for generous return policies. I am also thankful for great food, a boyfriend who insists on taking a bite of turkey heart before consuming the rest of the bird, and a wonderful family a safe distance away. Just kidding! We missed you all very much!
To prepare for our feast, I scoured many a cooking magazine, cookbook, and food blog as well as the family recipe collection in search of the perfect menu. To prevent myself from losing my mind, I made a master list where I kept track of all of the recipes that I planned to use, their sources, and all of the ingredients that they required. From there, I crossed off the ingredients that I already had and made a grocery list with the rest. Then I went to about five grocery stores (some of them twice) over the course of a few days, and I was ready to cook.
WEDNESDAY
The first dish: Apple Cider Cream Pie. Also on the agenda: drying out a few loaves of Rustica bread for stuffing.
Next: Cranberry Jello Salad.
And after taking a musical break, salting the bird.
THURSDAY
Draping the turkey in butter-and-cider-and-sage-soaked cheesecloth just before sticking it in the oven.
Rolls and stuffing in progress, and a smoky porter to keep me going.
The beginning of something delicious.
Fuel.
Stuffing prep.
More stuffing prep.
Basting.
Potato prep.
Turkey! We did it!
My timing was a bit off on the rolls, so they grew and grew and grew before baking, but they were still fluffy and delicious.
Carving the juicy bird.
Quality control.
The spread.
Recipes:
- Cider-Glazed Turkey with Lager Gravy (Food & Wine, November 2011)
- Cheesy Mashed Potatoes (improvised, with heart)
- Corn Casserole (my great-grandmother’s recipe – coming soon!)
- Chestnut Stuffing (based on a Martha Stewart recipe)
- Cranberry Jello Salad (my grandma’s recipe)
- Kale and Brussels Sprout Salad (Bon Appetit, November 2011 – made with hazelnuts instead of almonds)
- Dinner Rolls (The Bread Baker’s Apprentice)
Dessert:
- Brown Butter Pecan Praline Tart (Bon Appetit, November 2011 – made with walnuts instead of pecans)
- Apple Cider Cream Pie (Food & Wine, November 2011)
Hope you all had a great Thanksgiving!



































